Five ‘Holy Grail’ Lincoln Pennies Expected to Hit Auctions with Value Up to $840,000

In the world of numismatics, Lincoln pennies have always held a special place. This year, five rare Lincoln pennies are expected to hit auctions with estimated values reaching up to $840,000. These “holy grail” coins are highly coveted among collectors due to their unique minting errors and rare compositions, which make them incredibly valuable.

The Most Expensive Lincoln Pennies Up for Auction

Each of these pennies has a unique story and history that elevates its value, capturing the attention of collectors worldwide. From the iconic 1943-D Bronze Cent to other rare finds, these coins represent some of the most significant U.S. minting errors ever discovered.

Coin Name	Auction Price (USD)	Mint Location	Unique Feature	Rarity
1943-D Bronze Cent	$840,000	Denver	Bronze instead of steel	Only one known
1943-S Bronze Cent	$504,000	San Francisco	Bronze with zinc fleck	Very rare
1944-S Steel Cent	$373,750	San Francisco	Steel, one of two known	Only uncirculated
1943 Bronze Cent	$372,000	Philadelphia	Bronze instead of steel	Around 20 known
1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent	$348,000	Philadelphia	Bronze instead of steel	Approximately 10-15

1. 1943-D Bronze Cent – $840,000

The 1943-D Bronze Cent stands as one of the rarest Lincoln pennies, selling for a record-breaking $840,000. Struck by mistake in bronze at the Denver Mint during a time when pennies were made of steel to conserve copper, this is the only known 1943 bronze penny from Denver. Its unique olive-brown patina with hints of crimson and well-preserved luster make it a top choice among collectors.

2. 1943-S Bronze Cent – $504,000

The 1943-S Bronze Cent, sold for $504,000, is another incredible find. This coin, minted in San Francisco, was mistakenly struck in bronze, and features a rare zinc fleck on its surface. The coin’s unique history and sharp detailing, particularly in Lincoln’s hair and the wheat stalks on the reverse, make it a prized possession.

3. 1944-S Steel Cent – $373,750

The 1944-S Steel Cent, valued at $373,750, is one of only two known examples. Unlike other coins in 1944 that were minted from copper, this steel cent from San Francisco features a zinc-plated steel planchet in pristine condition. Known for its bright surface and detailed strikes, this coin is a collector’s dream.

4. 1943 Bronze Cent (Philadelphia) – $372,000

The 1943 Bronze Cent from Philadelphia fetched $372,000 at auction. One of approximately 20 bronze cents minted by mistake, it has a rich brown patina with hints of red. Discovered in 1957, the coin quickly gained fame, with rumors suggesting it could be traded for a new car. Its legend, combined with its scarcity, makes it one of the most valuable Lincoln pennies.

5. 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent – $348,000

This 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent, valued at $348,000, is one of roughly 10 to 15 known examples. Its deep, warm brown color with red accents gives it remarkable eye appeal. Struck on the wrong planchet during a time when steel was standard for pennies, this coin remains a collector’s favorite.

The market for rare Lincoln pennies continues to grow, with these “holy grail” coins representing some of the most valuable pieces of U.S. coinage history.

FAQs

Why are these Lincoln pennies so valuable?

These Lincoln pennies are valuable due to their unique minting errors, which make them rare and highly desirable among collectors.

What makes the 1943-D Bronze Cent unique?

The 1943-D Bronze Cent is unique because it was struck in bronze instead of steel, and it’s the only known example from the Denver Mint.

How many 1943 Bronze Cents exist?

Approximately 20 Philadelphia-minted 1943 Bronze Cents are believed to exist, making them exceptionally rare.

Why was steel used for pennies in 1943?

In 1943, the U.S. Mint used steel instead of copper for pennies to conserve copper for World War II efforts.

How much did the original owners of these coins pay?

Most of these coins were originally purchased for modest amounts, but their value has skyrocketed due to rarity and collector interest.